Cloud-led Future · Intelligence-driven Hotline +86 21 6228 0217 中文 | EN

New Expense-Allocation Rules Give Property Insurers a Solid Accounting Base for Rate Discipline

Overview

On 13 November, the general office of the National Financial Regulatory Administration issued the Notice on Strengthening Expense Allocation Management at Property Insurance Companies (Jin Ban Fa [2026] No. 88), while the China Association of Actuaries simultaneously released the Guidelines for Expense Allocation at Property Insurance Companies, effective 1 January 2027. The notice states its purpose plainly: to improve the truthfulness, fairness and comparability of financial data and to consolidate the foundation for operating-result accounting, product pricing and the discipline that reported terms must match actual practice.

The notice sets concrete requirements. Insurers must draft internal expense-allocation rules tailored to their own circumstances, specifying collection standards, allocation methods, indicator definitions and adjustment rules based on the business scenario where the expense arises. Allocation must follow the principle that the beneficiary bears the cost, with methods and indicators kept stable. On organisational treatment, head offices and provincial branches that do not directly conduct sales may not retain selling expenses; where they do sell, such expenses must be attributed to the sub-provincial branch issuing the policy, or to the provincial branch where no lower-level physical branch exists. A collaborative mechanism led by finance with departmental support is required, with management accountable for the truthfulness and accuracy of allocation. Requirements must be applied throughout cost accounting, product pricing and performance assessment with documented, traceable workflows. Rules, methods and core indicators must remain stable; any necessary change with a material effect on provincial-branch expense levels requires internal review, impact estimation and prompt reporting to the regulator.

The guidelines add technical detail. They reaffirm beneficiary-bears-cost and substance-over-form principles, accrual-based attribution to the actual beneficiary, and four operating principles of compliant accuracy, proper collection, reasonable allocation and stable comparability. Expenses split into direct expenses attributable to a specific institution, department, line or product, and common expenses requiring further allocation, with a stated preference for raising the direct share and lowering the common share. By cost behaviour they divide into fixed and variable; by business stage, into underwriting expenses, indirect claims expenses and administrative expenses. Methods include time-proportion, activity-driver and allocation-factor approaches, applied in one step or several. The covered expense scope matches non-site regulatory data reporting - commissions and brokerage, business and administrative expenses, taxes and surcharges, and indirect claims expenses treated as claim cost - with reinsurance and investment-related indirect expenses as optional references.

Background & Interpretation

1. Regulatory and Industry Context

This is not a rule built from scratch. The 2006 Expense Allocation Guidelines for Insurance Companies, which classified direct and common expenses, were abolished in August 2025 during a cleanup of normative documents. The August 2026 Comprehensive Governance Action Plan for Non-Motor Insurance explicitly required an expense-allocation guideline and standardised procedures, so the current notice and guideline amount to a reissue after repeal, linked to non-motor governance. The market pain points are explicit: coarse expense collection in some firms, bloated common-expense pools and highly subjective allocation methods, which weaken the accuracy of accounting information and distort fair competition. The regulator states that fictitious expenses, delayed booking used to circumvent approved and filed product rates, missing allocation systems or failed internal controls will draw supervisory measures or administrative penalties.

2. Core Drivers and Underlying Mechanisms

The first mechanism is closing the loop between pricing and accounting. If reported terms must match actual practice but common expenses can be flexibly shifted across lines, channels and branches, book expense ratios may diverge from real operations and dilute the constraint of rate filing. Tracing expenses to the actual beneficiary puts product pricing, result accounting and regulatory reporting on one cost basis. The second is organisational look-through. Head offices and provincial branches retaining selling expenses without direct sales activity have long been a grey zone; the new rule keys attribution to whether selling actually occurs and requires allocation to the policy-issuing branch, matching expenses to policy origin. The third is comparability and stability. Once chosen, allocation methods cannot be changed at will, and adjustments require impact estimation and reporting, preventing results from being managed across years or regions by switching allocation conventions.

3. Market Structure and Value-Chain Impact

For insurers, the most immediate impact is on systems and processes. Expenses must be tagged by business scenario at source, finance, actuarial, business and IT functions must share one set of allocation factors and dimension definitions, and management accountability moves internal-control responsibility upward. Smaller insurers face relatively higher system-rebuild and data-governance costs, and the push to raise the direct-expense share will expose structurally large common-expense pools. For product and channel management, a unified basis makes line-level cost ratios and channel expense ratios genuinely comparable, helping identify growth strategies reliant on expense spending and shifting enforcement of rate discipline from document checks to data look-through. For reinsurance and actuarial services, the defined reference scope and methods may raise demand for third-party accounting and advisory work. For regulatory statistics, aligning expense scope with non-site reporting reduces noise from definitional differences.

Implications & Outlook

In the near term, the run-up to 1 January 2027 will be spent on policy revision, system rebuilds and comparability treatment for historical data, with training and internal review workflows the priority. Over the medium term, better comparability should allow finer joint monitoring of filed rates and expense ratios, letting non-motor governance and motor-insurance expense transparency be assessed in the same accounting language. Variables to watch include the pace at which insurers file and implement internal allocation rules, industry-wide shifts in the direct-expense share, reported cases of allocation-factor changes, and the first supervisory actions over fictitious expenses and delayed booking. Converging conventions should make expense-ratio rankings and performance comparisons more credible, while also making visible some costs previously absorbed in common-expense pools.

Takeaways for Industry Participants

Property insurers should start early on business-scenario mapping and source-level expense tagging, define the boundary between direct and common expenses, and document allocation factors, dimension definitions and approval procedures for changes. System work should be scheduled backward from the 2027 effective date, leaving a window for restating historical data and validating comparability. Actuarial and product teams need to feed the new expense basis back into pricing and rate testing to check whether expense assumptions in existing products still hold. Branch management should recognise that revised selling-expense attribution changes local performance metrics and align with finance and business units in advance. Audit and compliance teams should treat allocation-method stability, traceability and adjustment impact estimation as priority checks, reducing the risk of being judged as having failed internal controls after implementation.

This column compiles industry information and shares technical perspectives; it does not constitute investment advice.